Discussion about this post

User's avatar
One Tiny Spark's avatar

Thank you for dissecting one of the foremost tales in the entire corpus of Abrahamic literature. I enjoyed reading the insights it provided. Which part of the story do you think constitutes the 'point of no return' if we were to analyse Joseph's story through the lens of the traditional three act structure? Thank you once again. Khadija.

Expand full comment
Joshua Moinian's avatar

Hi Rabbi,

Thank you for sharing this—such a great read. I’d love to get your perspective on a question that came to mind.

The reading highlights Yosef’s deep faith and understanding that his fate is intrinsically tied to God’s will and divine plan. Yosef’s attitude reflects an acceptance of his circumstances as opportunities to serve a higher purpose.

For example, you mention how Yosef does not become embittered or resentful about the years of hardship he endures. Instead, he trusts that his dreams and visions will come to fruition in God’s time, even if the path is uncertain or painful. This is evident in his refusal to complain about being forgotten by the butler.

You also touch on Yosef’s ability to succeed in any circumstance, which stems from his belief that God is guiding his steps. He focuses on making the most of each situation, confident that God’s plan is unfolding, even when it isn’t immediately visible.

Additionally, Yosef recognizes that his personal trials are part of a larger divine narrative. When he reveals his identity to his brothers, he reframes their betrayal not as their wrongdoing but as part of God’s plan to save lives during the famine.

In all of this, we see Yosef’s attitude as a combination of personal agency and submission to divine will. His success is due to his alignment with God’s purpose, which he embraces with unwavering faith and humility.

Now, here’s my question: If all of this is true, how can we explain why Yosef asked the cupbearer to put in a good word to Pharaoh to help him get out of jail?… “So if you keep me in mind when things go well for you, please do me the kindness of mentioning me to Pharaoh, and thus you will get me out of this prison-building.”

Wouldn’t true faith in God mean waiting for God to intervene instead of relying on human help? After all, his actions here seemingly led to him remaining in jail for more years as a punishment.

Eager to hear your response.

Best,

Josh

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts